The Day the Earth Stood Still (2008)
Directed by: Scott Derrickson
Starring: Keanu Reeves, Jennifer Connelly, Kathy Bates
I’ve been adamantly against this remake since I first heard about it, but I hadn’t seen it until the other day. This movie pretty much proves that I’m always right about everything forever, and also that the screenwriter, David Scarpa, should never work again.
This “remake” has little to no similarities to the original Day the Earth Stood Still. An alien comes to Earth in an effort to get humanity to stop screwing up the planet’s ecosystem, or he’ll destroy them all with his army of giant glowing spheres and giant robot that is apparently made out of billions of smaller robots. However, he’s shot as soon as he leaves his ship and is hustled off to a secret government research center. Once there, he escapes with the help of his powers of controlling electricity and goes off to meet another fellow alien that’s been living on Earth for years to see if the humans are really worth saving.
He then leaves with a doctor who helped him and her son to meet a scientist (John Cleese, for some reason) and ask HIM whether humans should be killed or not. The kid calls the cops on the alien and he starts the world destruction program thing whatever. Eventually the alien sees the mom and her son hugging over the grave of his dead dad and changes his mind, deciding instead to stop the evil robot thing. Ughhhhh.
My problem with this movie wasn’t that it had minor differences like glowing orbs instead of flying saucers and the fact that the alien had magic powers to blow people up and bring them back to life and things like that (althought that WAS stupid), my problem was that they took a film with a legitimate message and turned it into an action movie with an afterthought of ‘save the whales’ thrown in to try and make it meaningful. It’s kinda like they watched the original movie, COMPLETELY missed the point, and thought, “Oh man, I’d love to see that giant robot blow a bunch of shit up with that laser! LET’S MAKE A REMAKE!!”
On that note, I just want to mention again that I hope second-time screenwriter David Scarpa goes to sleep every night haunted by the fact that he couldn’t write believable characters or an interesting story to save his life, until he eventually dies a lonely, bitter old man. That… might be a LITTLE mean, but I think I’ve got my point across. Keanu spends the whole movie hating humanity until he has a walk with the kid where they don’t talk about shit, and then suddenly he’s moved because he hugs his mom at his dad’s grave. What the fuck kind of humanity-saving moment is that? I’m not asking for anything grandiose, I’d just like it to be something that made a lick of goddamn sense. How is that particular moment ANY different than the other seven times the kid mentioned his dad being dead and both of them being sad about it? Are you seriously telling me that the human race is saved because of a HUG? Grr… I can’t even talk about this awful story anymore.
The last thing I want to mention is that Keanu Reeves was not the worst part of this movie. He was bad, yes, but it was his standard kind of bad, and they obviously “wrote” this thing to play to his strengths (displaying no emotion, being confused). In total… this movie was exactly what I expected. Except that I didn’t really expect to be angry after watching it instead of just sad. No movie has ever made me this angry before.